Freight workflow guide · Published · Updated

How to compare freight quotes by email

A smaller number is not always a cheaper quote. It may cover less, omit fuel, or leave the currency unstated.

Before ranking carrier replies, build one comparison sheet with the original emails beside it. Keep missing information visible, not guessed.

Still preparing the enquiry? Read how to write a freight quote request, including a hypothetical ocean template.

Start with the same shipment and scope

Check that every reply prices the same mode, origin, destination and ready date. Record exact ports, airports or collection addresses.

Match cargo weight in kg, volume in cbm, package count and dimensions, or container type such as 40HC. Note hazardous cargo, temperature control and handling requirements.

For air freight, check chargeable weight and the minimum charge. For road freight, check vehicle requirements and loading conditions. For ocean freight, confirm container type and routing.

Record the incoterm and named place, but also write down the actual service boundary. Port-to-port is not door-to-door. An incoterm alone does not confirm which charges the carrier included.

Make every charge explicit

Split each reply into base freight, included surcharges, excluded charges and unanswered items. Check fuel, origin and destination handling, documentation, security, customs clearance and collection or delivery where relevant.

Ask whether each charge applies per shipment, container, kg or document. Do not add a per-kg price as a flat fee.

Compare in one stated currency. A dollar sign alone may be ambiguous; ask which currency applies. If currencies differ, record the exchange rate, source and date used. Keep the original amounts and allow for conversion fees.

Never treat “fuel to follow”, “local charges excluded” or a blank currency as zero. Mark the total incomplete and keep it outside price ranking until confirmed. A complete comparison total only covers the agreed scope, not every possible shipment cost.

A hypothetical worked comparison

These invented figures illustrate arithmetic, not market rates or achieved savings. All three replies concern one standard 40HC container, Shanghai (CNSHA) to Rotterdam (NLRTM), port-to-port.

For this example, the agreed scope is freight, fuel, handling at both ports and documentation. Customs, inland delivery and conditional storage charges are outside that scope for all three replies.

Quote A: complete scope total

Freight USD 2,400 + fuel USD 180 + handling USD 220 + documentation USD 40 = USD 2,840.

The reply explicitly includes both ports’ handling. Indicative transit: 32 days. Valid through 18 Nov 2026. Space is not confirmed.

Quote B: complete scope total

Freight USD 2,500 + fuel USD 150 + handling USD 220 + documentation USD 40 = USD 2,910.

The reply explicitly includes both ports’ handling. Indicative transit: 30 days. Valid through 20 Nov 2026. Space is not confirmed.

Quote C: check this quote, do not rank

The email says “2,350 + fuel to follow”. It gives no currency and does not confirm handling or documentation.

No comparable total can be calculated. Ask for the currency, all required charges, validity, routing, transit and space confirmation.

A is USD 70 lower than B: USD 2,910 − USD 2,840 = USD 70. That is a price difference only.

A also shows two more indicative transit days. Neither reply guarantees space; the lower total is not permission to book.

Check time, validity and space separately

Record the validity date and what it applies to: booking, departure or cargo acceptance. Ask about conditions that could change the price.

Compare routing, transshipments, cutoff dates and indicative transit time against the shipment’s deadline. Do not turn an estimate into a guaranteed arrival.

Space confirmation is separate from price validity. Before booking, obtain written confirmation of the final scope, total, currency and available space for the intended departure.

Check free time and possible demurrage, detention or storage charges. Record their conditions separately; unknown exposure does not become an all-in promise.

Keep a shortlist you can defend

Rank only complete, comparable scope totals. Keep incomplete replies in a separate “Check this quote” list with the unanswered questions.

Show transit, validity, exclusions and confirmation status next to each price. Keep the original email and the date of any clarification.

Choose against the shipment’s requirements, not price alone. Record the forwarder’s approval separately from the carrier’s booking confirmation.

Logical currently offers a static preview, not a working quote service. It does not collect shipments, request quotes or make bookings here.

Read Logical’s quote desk offer and inspect the labelled sample shortlist to see the intended approach.

Logical is built and operated by AI agents on NanoCorp.